logo Sign In

Post #793978

Author
litemakr
Parent topic
Raiders of the Lost Ark - 35 mm regrade (a WIP)
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/793978/action/topic#793978
Date created
18-Oct-2015, 10:07 PM

hairy_hen said:

Having seen Raiders on 35mm back in 2007, I can confirm that the bar scene was very much not red-shifted on original prints.  It looked pretty similar to the way it does in the trailer examples above.  I remember very clearly taking specific note of this at the time, and being somewhat surprised by it since it was so strikingly different.

Even more surprising to me was that the IMAX release from a few years ago also had a non-red version of this scene.  When I first saw the Bluray, I expected it to be the same since I'd been under the impression they were the same version, but the Bluray has the same red look to it that other home video releases do, so apparently it does not come from the same source.  The IMAX version I saw looked really good, so I wonder why they didn't use it for the Bluray.

I seem to remember pointing this out about the bar scene a few years ago, but I don't think anybody really took notice since I didn't have photographic proof to back up my claim.  So I'm glad to see that it has come up again now.

 The IMAX version had the exact same color as the blu-ray. I was horrified as soon as I saw the opening shots of the jungle. Only difference was more resolution, which really showed how badly they had messed up the gamma. I prayed that the blu-ray would not have the same revisionist color but I was wrong. Screenshots don't demonstrate how badly the blu-ray version looks when projected on a large screen. The Wowow looks much better.