imperialscum said:
I would go for KOTOR1 easily. The story and characters feel more "Star Wars" like.
I prefer the setting and planets in KOTOR1 as well. They are much more visually beautiful and this a huge factor for me.
KOTOR2 has too many ridiculous concepts to my taste (ridiculously powerful villain, immortal villain, etc.).
I would however have much more trouble to pick a favourite between KOTOR1 and original SWTOR story-related content.
I concur completely. The villain in KOTOR is to me the best since Vader, while in KOTOR II they villains are ridicilous. Also the sequel was so rushed that the ending came out of nowhere when I played it while the first one just became more and more epic and interesting until then end.