pittrek said:
The colours look pretty good, but the whole video is so dark... even the blacks look crushed.
The motion is "weird". There's even some motion smearing, I hope that's the correct term. It's nowhere as bad as the GOUT but it's pretty annoying. And I didn't notice it in further scenes.
Owen and the stuff behind his back - what's going on ? In some shots it appears like Owen's stable, but the background behind him is "dancing", in other shots the background looks almost like a static painting. In the "he doesn't exist anymore" shot the whole picture is "weaving", just like in the shot where Luke wants to go to the academy.
The shot of the two suns the white sun is shaking. It's extremely annoying.
The rest is pretty much great.
I agree that the colors look quite nice. I honestly never thought this print would look as good, color-wise, based on the early (and even more recent) samples. Not sure about the blacks being crushed. Probably not the best example to tell by, but doesn't seem unrecoverable based on this.
Regarding the 'dancing' I see some of what you're talking about and agree that having a time stamp would be useful to discuss more specifically. Seems to be incomplete stabilization and some single frame warping due to the scan itself. Noticeable in a few places.
Cleanup looks good, but still incomplete. The first night shot with the twin suns could use a bit in particular. And then from Luke's closeup to the end there are tramline issues. They're thin and migrate horizontally through static shots, so they should be removable to a decent extent. There's a rather bright one on the left in the very last shot.
Coming along nicely, overall.