AntcuFaalb said:

thejediknighthusezni said:

Does it make any sense to say that someone created the principle that 2+2 must equal 4 or that all circles must be round?

Yes, because we have no reason to believe that such rules hold beyond our plane of existence.

But even if 2+2 and circles are LIMITED to our plane and perhaps any similar planes, that very LIMITATION must then require that these principles apply to all planes.

If all US states are located in the Northern hemisphere at the present time, then that fact must apply to everyone in the Southern hemisphere even if there is no possibility, at present, of a US state being located there.