I don't think we should even be discussing this stuff on Blu-Ray.com. What's the point? Do we really need to call attention to ourselves like that?
And we're not even trying to get as clean and sharp and finely detailed an image as an official transfer from the negatives. We know that's impossible, and that's not our goal. If you saw the movie in a theater it wouldn't look as detailed as the negative either.
I wonder if these are the kind of people who don't think there's no point to digital reservations of original vinyl records, either. No point in arguing with them.