This is one of two fan edits I'm watching over this weekend - the second is The Blackened Mantle edit which I'm watching right now.

First impressions for this edit - I enjoyed it very much. I liked the minimal dialogue and finally someone has made a decent attempt at making Anakin less of a whiner and more of the person alluded to in Episode IV. He's much more stronger in this version than any other edit I've seen (no offense to the other fan editors) and so it makes his move to the Dark Side less obvious.

It's a little odd not hearing the John Williams score, but the music chosen for this edit works well. Was that a Thai song I heard late in the movie (at the very least a SE Asian pop song of some sort)

Overall, I enjoyed this a lot. The only thing that bothered me was the sound levels for when dialogue and sound effects were allowed through, but I'm guessing that's down to having to manipulate what's there already to kill the music soundtrack.

Good work!