Both versions win, but only one wins in each screenshot. I would choose DrDre's most of the time, but in bad scenes with huge aliasing issues that jump out (like the R2 and 3PO closeups), choose MagicSR. This is easy enough to do in a script. Yes, there will be elements that are better within each frame from either side, but when it is in motion, they are less noticeable unless they stick around for a long time which the aliasing tends to do for the entire scene. As long as the aliasing is minor, then filling the scene with more detail is better.