Quote
For instance, people thought the clone troopers in Episode II were real, but they weren't.
That only probes 1) That ILM did a great job and 2) that the people who complain about CGI are usually the ones that can't even detect what is CGI and what's not.
Quote
Why is it so hard for you to accept that some people might have assumed Vader was CGI?
I couldn't care less if he thought it was CGI, what bothered me is that he not only thought it was CGI but he was so quick to critizice that it looked sooooo CGI when in fact it wasn't a CGI shot. Again probing my point that "the people who complain about CGI are usually the ones that can't even detect what is CGI and what's not." and they are just complaining for the sakes of complaining.
Quote
Your's is the dumb argument
What is my argument again? Ohh yeah, that something that is not a computer generated image it's not CGI and that not everything that looks clean and shiny it's CGI. [sarcasm]Oh yeah you are right that is very dumb.[/sarcasm]