You guys should work together and scene by scene each of you post your best effort (and of course get the aspect ratio in agreement with each other) and then choose which version is best for each scene. If you don't agree, then let us choose :-). In my opinion the jaggies are totally distracting, so whenever there are jaggies, do what it takes to get rid of them (maybe do a mask of the problem areas and mix two versions in the same frames). Also, waxy smooth and glossy is not good either. Over-sharpened with halos is bad too.