I really like all the colors in your new Clip a lot it all feels very nice and polished.

I actually like everything about the new Dagobah matte (set) and the Spider I think it looks really excellent and far superior to the original matte.

I did notice a bit of mist animation on the right doing something strange, but as always the clip is probably an older version and that has no doubt been sorted by now. (Ignore that comment it's facebook compression)

Vader looks great fixing the no neck issue too. I never noticed that before today.

I am not in any way criticizing but Although I extremely enjoyed the new clip it really looks great. I will give my usual feedback and thoughts you have given me after the experience which was only 1 thing of your new additions and one from the original film.

1. Would we be able to see the upper gun of the x-wing on the side view cockpit as It enters the atmosphere through the blue haze?

2. Would the crashed x-wing miniature have smoke rising from the engines?

And that is it... But I also have to admit I really like the comment on the facebook page about adding a visible splash when R2 falls off the edge of the x-wing.

It was very pleasing to watch and I thoroughly enjoyed it :) Thanks very much