logo Sign In

-

Author
Time
 (Edited)

-SECTION 2 Overall-

Main Changes Throughout:

New titles and episode numbers for each film (Please note that since opening crawls will be gone that these titles will mainly affect menu names):

Rogue One:
Prologue

Han Solo:
Han Solo

Boba Fett
Boba Fett

Ep 4 A New Hope
Ep 1 Return of the Jedi

Ep 5 The Empire Strikes Back:                        
Ep 2 The Empire Strikes Back

Ep 6 Return of the Jedi:
Ep 3 A New Hope

Prequels Part 1 (Disc 2)

Ep 1 A Phantom Menace and Ep 2 Attack of the clones:  
Ep 4 Guardians of Peace

Clone Wars 1-4
Ep 5 The Clone Wars

Prequels Part 2 (Disc 3)

Clone Wars 5-9 Movies

Ep 3 Revenge of the Sith:
Ep 6 Shroud of the Dark Side

New Trilogy (Disc 4)

Ep 7 The Force Awakens:
Ep 7 The Force Awakens

Ep 8:
Ep 8 -

Ep 9:
Ep 9 -

Machete

Timeline with OLD numbers used (placement of “Han Solo” may change): Rogue One, Han Solo, 4, 5, 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, 9

(essentially just an updated longer machete order)

Machete Order

Removing all opening crawls to make marathons seamless.

Removing the credits for every film to make marathons seamless (they will be view-able through the menus, separate from their films)

Adding a new opening crawl to the beginning of Prologue that adds in more details.

Adding a short message about the time skip from ESB to Clone Wars

Adding a short message about the time skip from ROTS to Force Awakens






Opening Intros (in order):

1st Metro Goldwyn

2nd-20th Century Fox The Phantom Menace 2011 Blu-Ray opening (this opening is slightly altered from all other Star Wars Blu-ray openings): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9a1QMh6A_L8

3rd-Disney Original Intro High Quality: http://www.demo-world.eu/download-2d-trailers/?file=distributor_walt_disney_pictures-DWEU.mkv&pic=distributor_walt_disney_pictures.jpg

4th-Video game LucasArts intro (one with force lightening)

Author
Time

"Perfect" is a matter of opinion.

...can an admin please move this thread to the fan edits section?

Also, welcome to the forums Codeman.

Nobody sang The Bunny Song in years…

Author
Time

The "plot holes" and "horrendous dialogue" you list are nothing of the sort.

Author
Time

This sounds an awful lot like Star Wars Revisited. But your own take. All the more power to you, but yeah, this is in the wrong sub-forum. 

What’s the internal temperature of a TaunTaun? Luke warm.

Author
Time

As Silverwook is fond of pointing out, the mods are not omniscient (nor omnivorous...I don't think).  I've sent him a PM asking for the thread to be moved.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

See, omnivorous means to eat everything or to take everything in with the mind, depending on how it's used.  It was a play on omniscient, which means to have unlimited knowledge or understanding, which in this case refers to the fact that the moderators can't possibly know everything going on in every thread.

/ricolie

...

Oh wait, you were referring to the OP.

Author
Time

If you can fix any of those "plot holes" and still make the movie make sense, then you go right ahead.

Star Wars Revisited Wordpress

Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress

Author
Time

Codeman said:

The main source for this will be Harmy's Despecialized Editions, and color corrections of the blu-ray releases. The goal of this project will be to remove any imperfections so that Star Wars The Original Trilogy may be viewed without noticing any imperfections or shortcomings. Although I am making several changes with this project please note that I view the theatrical releases as the best official release of Star Wars and despise most of George Lucas's changes. However I feel implementing some cut content and some good changes that George has made will made to the overall experience of the films. Here are some videos that point out many of the changes made to Star Wars: 

Episode 4: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xezn-0xottw, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzGzI5g0SNc, 

Episode 5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGYuz4qBTUM

Episode 6: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XkDO2UxX4Lo&feature=iv&src_vid=GGYuz4qBTUM&annotation_id=annotation_375866

Smaller Changes Throughout: 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jA38cHUWLo

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2j4pVJHX_I

Example of the type of cleanup I would like to do for deleted scenes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QyreW6l9PLY&list=LL01X1Kkv0PZ3Q86v4VtoJpw&index=58

Feel free to disagree with these additions/changes/removals and contribute if you find anything that you feel the movie would be better with or without. I tried to list these in chronological order so please point out any that are out of order. Current list of mistakes/imperfections that I would like changed:

Plot holes (R2 and 3po walking across a hall during a fight unscathed, Gunners not shooting at an escape pod with no life forms, Alerting the entire station to their presence our main heroes sit for several minutes in a trash compactor that anyone fighting them could have looked down on, trash compactor monster on a space station?, Luke suddenly having a green lightsaber)

Movie mistakes (Death Star clock not matching up with countdown voice, storm trooper hitting his head, tunnel on detention level firefight looks like a wall)

Fixing scenes that are missing special effects (notably Obi-won when fighting Darth Vader in Episode 4)

Cutting down scenes that do not make sense but are still essential to the plot: Death star run (Tie fighters could have shot straight forward as shown in the previous dogfights)

Adding in and cleaning up deleted scenes. The main three that I would like added: Luke on his uncle's moisture farm seeing the battle and running to tell his friends, Luke reunion with Biggs (scene was added back in later special editions), and Luke building his lightsaber with his father talking to him

Removing horrendous dialogue/replacing with new dialogue ("Whats that flashing?" Fight in detention cell Luke:"Well why are you...." "Would you forget it I already tried it its magnetically sealed"-Says Luke only seconds after he fell in, "Help me"-Leah only seconds after saying brace it with something, "May the force be with you"-Mission briefer, "I can't see it!"-Biggs saying seconds later that he can't shake it "They came from behind!" "You were lucky you don't taste very good" "*Insert annoying Ewok sounds here*"May the force be with you"-Admiral Ackbar "Accelerate to attack speed"

Replacing entire shots with special edition scenes that could have been done at the time when the film was produced: Widened sandcrawler shot, Obi-won's home in the blu-ray, ships leaving Mos Eisly, some select frames when Luke and Obi-won enter Mos Eisly, Some select Cantina aliens replaced with special edition aliens, ships leaving to attack death star, special edition award ceremony, extended wampa shot, windows in cloud city, han solo's "jacket" (shadow) removed with alternate shots, slightly extended scene of Jabba's dancer falling in the pit but without cgi singers, Jabba's sail barge leaving for the pit, Darth Vader without eyebrows

Replacing old sounds with entirely new ones (particularly Obi-won's scream to scare off the sand people)

Scenes to change if possible but would not line up correctly: New emperor in Episode 5 (keeping the old dialogue but using the new look)

Changes I will not make: Cgi Millenium Falcon leaving (cool shot but does not fit with the feel of the rest of the movies), Continuity changes to line up with the prequels i.e. adding Temuera Morrison's voice over Jason Wingreen, Hayden replacing Sebastian's Ghost

 

Wow Codeman, all of the things you dislike about Star Wars are the very things I like the most. 

-G

Author
Time

TV's Frink said:

The "plot holes" and "horrendous dialogue" you list are nothing of the sort.

 To me droids walking through a laser firefight unscathed is a plot hole. The "horrendous dialogue" may not bug some but it takes me out of the movies.

Author
Time

I'm not sure you actually like Star Wars.

Author
Time

yeah... besides, how are the droids walking through the laserfire unscathed a plot hole exactly?  I mean you could say you don't like it or that it's a little unbelievable, but it doesn't really have any effect on the plot...

Author
Time

Darth Lucas said:

yeah... besides, how are the droids walking through the laserfire unscathed a plot hole exactly?  I mean you could say you don't like it or that it's a little unbelievable, but it doesn't really have any effect on the plot...

 Moved to a new section. Thanks for the input.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Codeman said:

TV's Frink said:

The "plot holes" and "horrendous dialogue" you list are nothing of the sort.

 To me droids walking through a laser firefight unscathed is a plot hole. The "horrendous dialogue" may not bug some but it takes me out of the movies.

 I moved it to a new section. Thanks you for your input.

Author
Time

Danfun128 said:

"Perfect" is a matter of opinion.

...can an admin please move this thread to the fan edits section?

Also, welcome to the forums Codeman.

 Thanks for the welcome!

Author
Time

Codeman said:

TV's Frink said:

The "plot holes" and "horrendous dialogue" you list are nothing of the sort.

 To me droids walking through a laser firefight unscathed is a plot hole. The "horrendous dialogue" may not bug some but it takes me out of the movies.

 Moved to a new section. Thank you for your input.

 I was happier with this response when I hadn't realized you gave the same response to Darth Lucas.  I'M A UNIQUE SNOWFLAKE AND DEMAND TO BE TREATED AS SUCH!

Author
Time
 (Edited)

TV's Frink said:

Codeman said:

TV's Frink said:

The "plot holes" and "horrendous dialogue" you list are nothing of the sort.

 To me droids walking through a laser firefight unscathed is a plot hole. The "horrendous dialogue" may not bug some but it takes me out of the movies.

 Moved to a new section. Thank you for your input.

 I was happier with this response when I hadn't realized you gave the same response to Darth Lucas.  I'M A UNIQUE SNOWFLAKE AND DEMAND TO BE TREATED AS SUCH!

Input was the same but I'll try my best to give you unique responses Mr. Snowflake sir.

Author
Time

If possible I would but redoing lines that several well known characters say would be very difficult "I'm Luke Skywalker I'm here to rescue you" and both Vader and the Emperor say "Skywalker". If you can send me convincing audio files with skywalker replaced then I would use it but at the moment that would be very hard to do.