logo Sign In

Post #759456

Author
ElectricTriangle
Parent topic
Info: The films of Sergio Leone - The best available versions...
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/759456/action/topic#759456
Date created
25-Mar-2015, 9:59 PM

The Aluminum Falcon said:

captainsolo said:

From what I've heard the German FAFDM used MGM's transfer but did so without the extra processing and DNR MGM applied so that specks, dirt and grain are more visible.

This is true, yet I still stand by my assessment that the IT BD looks better overall than the DE BD. The MGM master, even with the extra processing taken off, just looks terrible to my eyes. 

That said, the IT does not have English audio. Though, both the 5.1 and mono have been synced to it, the latter by a member of this forum.

I would agree. The IT has much better colors and looks more natural, even if it is softer. The German/MGM transfer has worse colors and a ton of a lot of sharpening and edge enhancement.

The major difference between the German and MGM version is that the MGM has an auto dirt remover applied. Other than that they look the same. I don't think the MGM has any noticeable waxy-style DNR applied to it compared with the DE.

Who synced the mono to the IT? I would love to get that.