Hello.

It is not easy to criticize something without coming over as harsh. There is the slight possiblity that one, committed to an artistic work looses the view of relevance, might be colors, tones such fundamental things that become even harder to grasp with increasing commitment.

So I saw the sandcrawler scene in which is undeniably the best fan-edit of a pop cultural piece of art, trying to recreate that based on original sources and endless skill, I can't even touch a microscopic level of that. I'm a nobody and I have near no experience in video-editing nor the tools to do so.

So I tried to improve the colors in that sandcrawler scene and thought that's quiet an improvement, I wanted to share that. And I was slightly surprised to have actually offended anybody. Because there should be absolutely no personal perception of what I did. I was just trying to help.

But then I realized that your fan-edit is not my work and I have probably no right to criticize your decisions. I'm absolutely convinced the colors in the scene are way off, so simply making the image look worse because some source says so, felt ignorant and irritating.

Thank you for your work and may the best come out of Star Wars. I will delete my posts in your thread, but if you like to share, feel free.