imperialscum said:

Ryan McAvoy said:

imperialscum said:

Citizen Kane... I don't like it

Obviously this statement calls in to question the validity of your opinions on everything else.

Saying that an opinion can be valid or invalid is pretty much one of the must stupid things one can say. Especially when it comes to an opinion of an art.

Firstly, it was obviously a joke.

Secondly, I didn't say your opinion was invalid. The intent of the joke was to suggest that 'not liking Citizen Kane', was a first sign of diminished mental competence. The kind of mental incompetence that would legally invalidate documents such as a Will.

Would somebody stating that "Jar-Jar Binks was the most emotionally moving character ever comitted to celluloid" not cause you treat their subsequent statements with suspicion? Can somebody not have poor judgment? Is the word "taste" simply something I imagined?