Kabal said:

As for Episode I: No, the German dubbing doesn't make it any better... unless you consider being punched in the balls repeatedly by a German person to be a better thing than getting your balls busted by an American guy.

Well, "less bad" is still some form of "better". And I didn't say it's less bad because the people speak german, but because the dub dimished the effects of some of the bad dialog. It would still be a better version if the german dub was retranslated in english, it wouldn't make the story less boring, but it would still be a slight improvement. After watching the Plinkett reviews multiple times, I was actually a bit disappointed not to hear things like "I wish I could just wish away my feelings".