imperialscum said:

DominicCobb said:

I'm just saying that the ghost Anakin is not recognizably the dying Anakin.

And that's your opinion. I say the two are easily relatable.

DominicCobb said:

I am not saying that Luke (and the audience) would not realize who the ghost was supposed to be.

Well in fact you said Luke would not recognise the ghost which is the same thing as not realising it (or if we are really precise recognition is an essential step before realisation).

So it is an issue of semantics.

This discussion has drifted so far away from what I originally wanted to say about it that I feel there is no need for me to participate further.