It might come as a shock to some people that I've never seen any of Ady's edits. (Aside from some clips.) If he chooses to use his real name on them, that's his choice, but this site largely thrives on the anonymity of it's members.
Expressing criticism is fine, but coming into this thread to do so can only be viewed as provocative. (Start a thread in off topic if you're so inclined.) Unlike Lucas' creative choices the past 17 years, it's easy enough to avoid a fan edit you don't like.