Hal 9000 said:

Well, a few things I removed for Sharkey's Edition are reinstated, including more Arwen stuff in TTT along with Aragorn being separated from the pack. Kerr has done some great stuff for ROTK, including use of the palantir. He and I have been keeping these things under wraps and collaborating together, so I don't want to spill too many beans. The most concise thing I can say is that while it is less strictly "purist" than our former efforts, it's still respectful of the books and of the original films themselves.

Ah so not strictly a 'book edit' then unless you and Kerr have 2 versions planned?

It sounds interesting though!

I found Kerr's Red book edits, well most of them, I couldn't get book one, so it starts at Rivendell.

If you know of a link to part one could you email it to me please at lotr@jandcwoods.co.uk