I predict it will be as weird as watching Into Darkness if you are a Star Trek OS fan.
It looks as like Star Wars as the prequels did only in a different way (aging on new craft never made sense at least here the beat up stuff looks old enough to be beat up).
The average public viewer will think it's the most amazing thing evar buoyed along by the media reminding people how crap the prequels were.
The ball droid and Cumberjack voice over don't fill me with too much optimism and this is from someone who thought the teaser for TPM was something worth viewing on dial-up.