As for the fans, not a day goes by that the fans don't complain about something with this team. After signing him, people were practically ready to declare Jeff Garcia the savior of the franchise.
A couple weeks ago, they were ready to hang him.
So, a missed 2-point conversion wouldn't have made a great deal of difference.
Personally, I go for 2.
My thinking, I've been lucky against these guys all day. I don't want to see that luck run out in overtime.
Which is what happened.