Hm, interesting take - changing Ani to Luke - but should Maul still be the Sith Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan duel or change that too ?

if changed to Vader (if he is still Ani) problem is, that he knows of Luke - if NOT Anakin, then where is Ani (or do we have another "Vader"?)

Lucas got himself and us into a mess and without fresh material this gordon knot isn't easy to undo ...

I would like to have the PT be more a story of the Clone Wars (alike our WW1), with pre-imperial technology and seeing the Jedi as the heroes which Obi-Wan promised us - making Anakin something like "Baron von Richthofen", real knights of the sky ;-)