muddyknees2000 said:

ray_afraid said:

I don't need to know the whys, but I'd like it to at least be consistent.
In Star Wars, Obi-Wan disappeared because he's a wizard of some kind and that's what happens.
In Jedi, Yoda disappears because the first film established that that's what happens. Anakin doesn't, but he was a bad guy, so maybe he doesn't get the same rewards.... only he does. So it doesn't make sense.
Then the PT made it all even worse and made no effort to explain this weird thing that happens twice for no reason except maybe to avoid having an old man sliced in half on screen in an adventure for all ages.
So, I say all Jedi who die but don't disappear can't come back or contact the living. All who come back as telepathic ghost people should also disappear when they die.
Again, I don't need to know the whys, I'd just like consistency.
KnowwhatImean?

yeah, I don't disagree with that....as long as it's left vague and not given a silly explanation ala George.

Yeah, same here. The official explanation that 005 posted is ridiculous!

But, I seem to remember Ady saying he wouldn't be making Anakin disappear...
Did I make that up?
And if not, is he still firm on that decision?

It may make the funeral pyre scene a bit strange as Luke would just be torching the suit...
But I think it would still work as personal closure for Luke- a funeral for his father and destroying the visual remains of his dark side.

Any opinions?