logo Sign In

Post #726599

Author
pittrek
Parent topic
What Special Edition changes (if any) did people like?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/726599/action/topic#726599
Date created
9-Sep-2014, 12:44 PM

Wow, I never wrote my list? I thought I did. So ....

1997 A New Hope

- the new Fox logo

- dewbacks (even when I think they're overused)

- the new sandcrawler model

- the rebel fleet leaving Yavin 4 next to Lorne, but I HATE the next shot

- I have a feeling that I like some of the trench battle shots, but I'm not willing to re-watch it just to make a list

2004 ANH

- the Jabba scene (I'm probably the only person on this planet who likes it)

- the corrected cellblock matte painting

2011 ANH

- I hate this shit, I've seen it once and I never plan to watch it again

1997 ESB

- the new Fox logo

- the new wampa scenes - I LOVE them ! I was always hoping they add the whole subplot, but at least they added the shots which explain what actually happened to Luke

- I can't decide about the Cloud City shots - while I like what they TRIED to do, the actual execution looks pretty poor to behonest

2004 ESB

- can't remember ANY improvement

2011 ESB

- I hate it

1997 ROTJ

- the new Fox logo

- the new Sarlacc - it FINALLY doesn't look like a butthole! But the rest of the scene is still as stupid as it always was

2004 ROTJ

- nothing

2011 ROTJ

- nothing

2001 TPM

- nothing

2011 TPM

- the colour correction on most scenes, and the better cropping

200x AOTC

- nothing

2011 AOTC

- nothing

2006(?) ROTS

- nothing

2011 ROTS

- just the tiny fact that this is the first time a theatrical VIDEO was released on home video