A new Superman however. I think the casting can work, with Routh anyways. (And Topher). I really hope they move away from the old series more than you guys say they are going to...Its not that I dont trust you guys. I just hope they try and make something new, to get a new interest in the character/story/etc.
I agree that there are a lot of ways to interpret Superman. I think he is incredibly dense as a character. Id really like to see somebody tackle that aspect...Singer has the talent to do that story wise, I just dont know how the studio will want the movie to turn out? If they try to compete with Spiderman I dont think it will be as successful. They need to have their own style with this movie to make it work.
EDIT- Regicidal, did you not like the Punisher(recent)? Also, im glad to see some others who enjoyed the Hulk.