INVAR said:

I think I recall reading somewhere on this thread, not exactly sure where to be exact - but that suggestions for this edit are now **closed**.

'Closed' as in 'ended', 'fini', 'over', 'shut', 'the time is past', etc., etc., etc.

Perhaps our incessant meddling and opinions would be better suited to the ROTJ:R thread from this time forward, yes?

Let us leave the Artist alone to tweak and finish this work as he sees fit. I am absolutely positive almost all of us are going to be awestruck and impressed with what he did to make our favorite film of all time, truly - perfect.

There is nothing more irksome to those creating, to have designs by committee constantly ringing in the ears while attempting to complete a vision.

INVAR please try to recognize the difference between trying to be helpful and making suggestions. I think this miniature work especially trying to re-create lighting conditions correctly Is a tricky thing indeed.

I have done lighting in the past and It is not easy to light stuff correctly, It's an art form all on to it's own and with many tricks and out of the box thinking to get the results and mood correct.

This miniatures artist Mathew Albanesse has some very good techniques in achieving fantastic lighting states on his miniatures, I also believe there are breakdowns on how he got the end results which also could prove useful in terms of lighting so I thought I would make you aware of this work if you was not already. Please see the link below.

http://www.amusingplanet.com/2013/08/magical-miniature-worlds-by-matthew.html

I hope this can be of some help too.