logo Sign In

Harmy's STAR WARS Despecialized Edition HD - V2.7 - MKV (Released) — Page 488

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Actually the 1980 Latino dub is a merger from two different sources, both of which came to me, unlabelled, audio-only.  One or both may have ultimately come from you.  Most of it is from a very high quality source that had about three locations where English audio was still present, and those three areas were patched over using a lower-quality source blended with the isolated score to make the transitions more seamless.  If you are responsible for either or both of these sources, thank you very much!

EDIT: More details about how this track was assembled can be found here.

Project Threepio (Star Wars OOT subtitles)

Author
Time

Good documentary, when will we get the other 3 parts ? :-)

A few points

1) why do you use only Williams' Oscar? I think a better way would be to start with a montage of all Star Wars oscars - I checked and all of them (or most) appear to be on youtube in pretty good quality

2) Obi-wan's scream - please use all versions, not just the first and the last

3) just a tip/question - do you plan to do a more detailed comparison of all (or the most obvious) changes done to Star Wars over the years?

Author
Time

A few more thoughts - shouldn't you mention the PDEs too? If you read these threads, many people are confused about how many different versions are there. Any chance you could mention with just a few sentences what are the differences and why should people skip the previous versions?

You (or the narrator) mention(s) 2 kinds of preservations - laserdisc transfers and DE. Isn't it worth mentioning film preservation too? You know, 8mm, 16mm and maybe with 1-2 sentences mention that a couple of fans are doing a 35mm transfer (possibly without mentioning Puggo or -1 if they won't like it). It would make sense to me to mention these projects here, probably between laserdisc transfers and the DE, because later (I assume) you will be mentioning you used material from these projects?

If you talk at the beginning about the cultural impact of Star Wars, wouldn't be it useful to use a minute or two from either the TV intro or the "Making Of" documentary?

Author
Time

OK, let me start by saying, that I have had the scripts for this documentary checked and "approved" by at least ten members here, like half a year ago and they are staying the way they are. But there are seven parts planned altogether, this is just the introduction and you'll notice, that it's called Introducing the Despecialized Edition, not introducing Fan Preservations - so the preservations I chose to talk about here are those, which are relevant to what I'm talking about at the moment - I mention LD preservations, because I use that to lead up to talking about the GOUT, which is itself basically just a LD preservation and then I mention the preservations made from the GOUT and those combining different sources, because it leads up to the DeEd - at that time, there were no 35mm preservations - it may have been good to mention Puggo Grande but I talk about it in the later part and it isn't important for the story being told in this part - it all has internal logic :-)

Some of the other stuff you mention will be addressed in the other parts. The parts will be as follows:

- "Introducing the Despecialized Edition"
What is the DeEd and why it was made.

- "Introducing the changes"
Showing the changes made to the movies and how the changes were discovered (005's galleries).

- "Introducing the Rontoscoping"
Talking about and showing the removal of changes with rotoscoping.


- "Introducing the Sources"
This you've of course already seen but it will be re-cut slightly, as some segments will be used in the other parts.

- "Introducing the Colors"
How the color correction was done.

- "Introducing the Soundtacks"

I'd dearly love to include this one but I cannot with clear conscience attempt to do it myself - I could do the video side of it, but not the audio side and the script. The request for help with this still stands.

- "Introducing the Versions"
What are all the different versions, including the PDEs.
This one will be expanded to also talk about and show the latest versions of ESB and ROTJ.

As to using all the other Oscars, I think it would get boring pretty quickly and one is all that is needed to illustrate the point - the other awards are introduced by showing the corresponding segments from the movies.

With Obi-Wan's scream, again, it is used to illustrate a point, not to analyze all the different changes and versions and I think that showing the two most different versions serves that purpose best.

Author
Time

Harmy said:

Does anyone else have this problem?

 Nope, I was able to download it yesterday and the link still works today.

Author
Time

Beber said:

I've begun the English subtitles, since my job is actually to make subtitles, but English is not my native language, so some proof-reading will be needed. I can take part in the French translation, though.

 Beber, if you send me your finished SRT, I'll proof-read it and make corrections for English.  (I correct a lot of my own downloaded subs)

Subscribe to HarmyNews!

“Evacuate ...in our moment of triumph? I think you overestimate their chances.”

Author
Time

I also live in the US, and both links work for me.

I find it amusing to see all those workprints in the related files column :P

Nobody sang The Bunny Song in years…

Author
Time

I'm in the U.S. and the links are working for me as well.  Slow speed, but it's going using JDownloader.

Subscribe to HarmyNews!

“Evacuate ...in our moment of triumph? I think you overestimate their chances.”

Author
Time

MrPib said:

Harmy said:

Does anyone else have this problem?

Also, you could try this: http://www.ulozto.net/xtRatFDp/introducing-the-deed01-wp-mp4

Or loading the link into JDownloader.

 The original link and this link don't work.  I'm in the US.

Jdownloader of the original link didn't work, either.

 I get this message, im from the UK

Soubor je momentáln? nedostupný, zkus to, prosím, pozd?ji.
Pokud se jedná o tv?j soubor, obra? se na podpora@ulozto.cz, rádi ti pom?žeme.

Author
Time

Just watched the doc introduction and looks great so far. Can't wait to see the final version. Thanks for all your hard work, Harmy!

Author
Time

With all due respect, after having watched the original youtube documentary documentary several times and now watching this, it just seems like major overkill. You were much more succinct in the youtube video and this just seems to go on and on. The ending "interview" seems more like you set up the camera yourself and recorded yourself responding to an invisible interviewers questions. I would leave it at the original documentary, IMHO.
Just my 2 cents...

Author
Time
 (Edited)

The original link worked just fine for me today.

I thought overall it was great but I do agree that the Williams Oscar clip doesn't feel very affective. His work was relatively unaffected compared to most of the other departments that won that year.

So as a potential skeptical viewer who might be watching this it does nothing to make me sympathetic to the project or the plight of the OUT.

Keeping in mind that the narrative script is finalized, there's a couple of ways I think that segment could be improved.

The first would be to replace Williams with the Oscar acceptance for Visual Effects. The quality of the clip isn't that great but their work was the most hard hit by the SE.

The second would be to create a quick montage of all of their wins. Which could go something like this:

"And the winner is...[quickly cut between the different presenters saying "Star Wars"]

Or:

And the winner for: [cut in quick succession to the award name (Film Editing, Sound, etc.] is...STAR WARS. *APPLAUSE*

That would help emphasis what an impact the film made on the industry.

Anyway, that's just my two cents. =)

Forum Moderator
Author
Time

Yeah, I remember, when I was writing the script, Williams' was the only one I found but it would have been better the way you suggest - maybe I'll still re-edit that.

Author
Time

I've been Googling for a bit and can't find any proof to put behind this, but I swear that on the VHS copy of Star Wars we had when I was a kid, the blaster shots by the crew of the Tantive IV during the opening skirmish were not red. I almost want to say that the blaster shots were all changed to red for the THX remastered 1996 tapes, but it might actually have been for the SE release and on. If that's the case, then some of the source material for Despecialized must have featured this - is it in any of them? And if it is, are there any plans to restore it? I'm pretty sure the Tantive IV crew's blaster bolts were blue, while the stormtroopers' were red. Or I might just be crazy.