Let's see ... first, I have to list what I've seen him in (besides the PT).

Awake

Higher Ground

In the Mouth of Madness

Life as a House

His role in In the Mouth of Madness was less than insignificant, so I'm disregarding it. Of the remaining three, I've only seen Awake recently; the other two I haven't watched since the early '00s.

So -- for now -- I have to tentatively say that Awake is the best with either Higher Ground or Life as a House being the worst; should I watch either of the latter two in the near future, I may revise my evaluation.