DominicCobb said:
Regarding the Ben's hut scene, I'm a little confused. Everyone seems to say that ady's version follows the script. But it doesn't. I've looked at the script, the theatrical cut follows the scene exactly as it was written. However, ady's version does flow well and it seems as if the scene was shot with that sequence of dialogue in mind. Can someone clarify this for me?
From what I understand, Ady's version is the scene as it was originally shot. That is why there are no continuity errors in it, naturally. It was then later re-edited in post-production due to what the filmmakers felt was a pacing issue.
I happen to agree with this, and that is why I prefer the theatrical version. I don't mean to disrespect Ady's decision in his rearrangement, it's just my opinion. I never set out to say that Ady is wrong, nor did I imply that those who like his edit of that scene are wrong.
I just have my preference, and I felt it was worth explaining why, that is all.