My first reaction was to hit eject on the DVD player because I thought the disc was scratched. You know how when a disc gets scratched it goes all... pixel-y I guess? That's what I thought... I had no idea at that point that they had changed him in. I was... not disappointed (at the time, I didn't notice the difference in quality between the two trilogies, if I may show my unfortunate youth)... but confused. Not to mention at that time I hadn't seen any promotional photos or video from ROTS so I didn't even recognize him as Anakin... he really did look quite different (imo) from his appearance in AOTC.

EDIT: Also, I really like that the title of this topic is Hayden is ROTJ instead of in. It's almost like some crappy direct-to-video Steven Seagal Movie.

"Coming this summer to DVD... The sequel to Star Wars and The Empire Strikes Back! Hayden Christianson IS Return of the Jedi!"