_,,,^..^,,,_ said:

Then, with a quite good "polished" image, at first I thought to add a grain plate to it, but then I decided to not apply it, because it was not part of the animation "soul"... did I take the right decision?

Not all people love grain. It's a matter of taste.

Then i guess you did good.

I see that you're asking about this, obviously reading my comment on the BATB thread.

Well, adding grain to an already processed video is not very good, so you took the right decision in that regard. But I said I'll add grain just to fake a filmic experience.

Of course the ideal would be to have a 35mm film reel of the film to preserve, and in that situation, a removal of grain would be sacrilege to me!