Harmy said:
But he never said your OPINION was invalid!!! He said the arguments you used to support that opinion were invalid and I agree.
Oh, and I certainly hope the original trilogy won't get a remaster like LOTR FOTR, because we've already had two releases of Star Wars with completely f*cked up colors ;-)
And I politely disagree, my breaking the fourth wall argument is valid and has been from the very beginning and nothing anybody has said has changed that as you yourself have admited.
You yourself in your second last post said that whether or not the ESB frame your posted breaks the fourth wall is definately something to argue about, so my argument saying that that frame in particular breaks the fourth wall has validity to you as well. So how is my argument invalid when that is all I was saying, that that ESB frame breaks the fourth wall and thats why it was cropped by GL? You just admited it was valid and worth arguing over. In terms of breaking the fourth wall, that is the only frame that I've ever talked about, I have never mentioned the Star Wars frame because I don't feel its an issue there due to the shadows covering most of the visible frame in the corner. The argument might be invalid for the other ESB frames but I was never arguing that it was valid for those anyway, only for the one you just posted.
So now that we've established that the breaking the fourth wall argument in relation to the uncropped ESB frame you posted is valid and built on solid ground, whether you agree or not, some do, some don't as you said, can you see how stating an argument that is clearly valid as invalid is essentially the same as calling that person's valid opinion invalid and is therefore an incredibly conceited and offensive thing to do? All debates would end up in fights and insults being hurled everywhere if everybody was calling everybody elses opinions invalid because they felt their arguments were invalid. If everybody is respectful, you get an interesting debate. If everybody calls everybody elses arguments invalid, you get a punchup. I know which I prefer, most of the time anyway haha
As for getting a remastered Star Wars Original Trilogy, colours can be fixed but detail can't be created out of nothing. I'd much prefer a 4K remastering of the three OT with all the lovely grain and detail intact but messed up colours to nothing at all like we have now.