Everyone's mind will be blown when kk650 reveals himself to be...

GEORGE LUCAS!

All kidding aside, I can see both sides of the discussion having merit. The only cropped shot that absolutely makes 100% to me in existing at all, would be the shot on Bespin, with the Cloud Cars flying outside the window of the Falcon. It DOES make the focus of that shot more on the Cloud Car than on the Falcon's passengers, which makes sense to me. Other than that, I could go cropped or uncropped, and will still be grateful when ESB:R is finally released!