kk650 said:
brash_stryker said:
kk650 said:
GL agrees with me, hence the cropping, we agree to disagree, there's not much left to be said.
So would JarJar Binks. What's your point? The fact you're using such logic on THIS FORUM of all places carries no weight at all. This forum only exists because of George's misguided choices.
What you've said here has exactly proven my point. Essentially what you're saying is because GL agrees, you disagree, without weighing the merit of the change he's made. I know for a fact that there are others on this forum that are able to see beyong this viewpoint but I suspect that many will not be able to be found here in this thread, where every change is treated is sceptisism at best and disdain at worst.
Just because this forum was formed in response to GL and his SE changes doesn't mean that we can't move beyond seeing things so black and white, whatever changes GL does is wrong, how it originally was is right etc. etc. I want to believe that people here are openminded enough to move beyond that frame of mind and give him credit for some of the changes which are improvements IMHO.
Which, if you read one of my earlier posts, is EXACTLY what people are doing in here. If i was of the mindset that everything George is doing is wrong THEN WHY WOULD I BE KEEPING A LOT OF THE CHANGES HE MADE? If i was of the closed mindset that everything in the original was better, then why would i be even doing these edits? Wouldn't i just stick to doing a preservation of the theatrical versions and make NO changes to it?