kk650 said:

I'm afraid i'm going to have to agree to disagree about the curved frame of the window being more visible in the ANH shot, to my eyes it is clearly more visible on the uncropped ESB shot, hence why I believe the cropped framing is better. The breaking the fourth wall argument is in MY OPINION very much valid and you thinking that it is invalid is YOUR OPINION, not absolute fact like you seem to believe from your statement.

Your work on Star Wars Revisited was well done but you might want to reign in the ego a touch and show a little more respect for the opinions of others, your opinion is worth no more than anybody elses.

I don't think it's the case of it being an ego at all, but your argument actually being invalid with regard to the curved edge of the window frame. *I* can certainly see slightly more of the curve in ANH shot just like Ady said. You assert that you can "clearly" see more of it in the uncropped ESB shot. As far as I'm concerned that's not the case as I'm looking at it right now.

Your opinion on which is better is fine. Everyone is entitled to an opinion. Ady was just pointing out that the logic you're using to justify you preference doesn't seem to be reflected in the actual image.

If he seemed impatient, remember that he's probably spent more time looking at that shot than you have eating cooked dinners. It's probably just frustration. :)