sonofjones said:

well to be far it's kinda easy to get off topic. The edit is in it's final stages, and there's very little to suggest that a) isn't already in the edit b) hasn't already been rejected and c) could realistically be added in at this point. Ady's work has consistantly been excellent so the only thing left to be said is terrific work and can't wait for the edit to be released, and those have both been said countless times. So the only thing to really talk about is the future edits, especially those (ESPECIALLY the PT) will have far more fundamentally different edits than ANH:R and ESB:R have produced

....which is why I suggested the thread that was created for the sole reason of these alternative topics of discussion (that is, related to the Revisited saga but not necessarily Episode V)

You just said yourself the only things left to discuss are things that could realistically be added to Episode V. Anything else is clogging up the thread and might mean that important stuff getting buried.

We're all guilty of going off topic once in a while, but don't try and be a smart ass about it when I was polite and offered the relevant place to discuss it.