frank678 said:

vbangle said:

kk650 said:

Cool, thanks for the feedback.

The balance looks good to me as well across the whole film. Those settings are meant to be for the classic version though, I've got a nice 'matte' feeling going with the SW and ROTJ classic settings, do you feel that it looks a little too saturated?

This clip below uses the same settings as the previous clip but with reduced saturation. Do you prefer how this clip looks to the previous clip for the classic setting?

https://mega.co.nz/#!X8ZTWLzL!wDIQLrUTy045tR_qxhWPNEg9DwBj1b9ZTIxXveKjld8

Took a look at both, and I think you know what I like by now. I prefer the previous look, not this one with its reduced saturation settings.

I agree with vbangle I prefer the first clip. As far as I know ESB and ROTJ were not deliberately designed to look slightly muted, as Star Wars was.

Slightly off topic - have you checked out the Australian TV broadcast of ROTJ that recently appeared - it seems to have some really punchy colours in it, might be worth cross referencing if you are still trying out different palettes.

Hmm, its interesting that you like the first clip more, I was pretty sure that most people would prefer the second. Andrea, where are you when I need you haha

I'd love to check that out. How can a get a hold of the Australian TV broadcast of ROTJ? Doesn't it have the same colour palette as the german hdtv stream, i.e. the overall blue tint that the blu-ray also has?