Based on the lack of feedback it seems i'm not the only one unable to decide between those two clips in terms of brightness.

It's not important now though because I'm scrapping the colour settings for those two anyway, luke's fleshtones are still too red in the hut IMHO, I only noticed it by watching these clips numerous times. The Empire Strikes Back blu-ray transfer has so much red in the fleshtones that they are really difficult to get right across the whole film, I get them right in one scene, only for the overly reddish fleshtones to appear again in a later scene. I think i've got a hold of the red fleshtones problem now though.

I'll put a clip up from the battle of hoth using my latest settings soon so you guys can let me know what you think of the colours.