SidVichyssoise said:

There are aspects of the 1997 Special Edition (but not subsequent DVD/Blu-Ray alterations) that don't bother me at all, so a definitive Star Wars for me would have some but not all of these. Two exceptions would be Greedo not shooting at Han and keeping Sebastian Shaw as the ghost of Anakin. Does anybody else out there fall into this camp?

I feel the same way. Perhaps not about every aspect.

I'd actually be interested in making a LOTR style extended cut that even adds in some of the deleted scenes. I'm obnoxious like that :P

All that said, I like the theatrical cuts the most. This hybrid idea would be more like a fun project.