logo Sign In

Post #687160

Author
Easterhay
Parent topic
"Bring my shuttle."
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/687160/action/topic#687160
Date created
1-Feb-2014, 6:03 PM

doubleofive said:

darth_ender said:


My understanding is that the redub was not JEJ recording a new line, but rather a discarded line originally intended for ANH.

http://filmsound.org/starwars/starwars-AQ.htm
I will always call BS on that. No one uses the word "stardestroyer" in the movie, and Vader never left his ship that he would need to alert it to prepare for it! He starts on the SD, moves to the Blockade Runner, is on the Death Star, then on his TIE Fighter. Where would "Alert my Star Destroyer to prepare for my arrival" fit in? When he left the Blockade Runner? I know the rough cuts were long, but that's ridiculous.


Although I agree - I never believed the line was a leftover from A New Hope either - no-one refers to Leia's ship as a blockade runner either in the film and I don't remember the term TIE fighter being used either. So, the line could easily have been in the script and could easily have been said in the movie...however, the voice that reads that line in this added scene does not sound like James Earl Jones. That's what clinches it for me. It doesn't even sound like (god help us) David Prowse.