Humby said:

@OBI-WAN37

I'll give you the Palpatine/Anakin discussion as decent dialogue. But it's not great. The bigger issue with it, however, is why Anakin felt it was perfectly normal for the Chancellor to be dabbling in Sith legend. Why is a supposedly good character telling Anakin (a Jedi) that the Jedi are no different than the Sith. Anakin finds all of this perfectly normal, and it makes him look completely daft.

At this point I'm too tired to think of the possible flaws in your logic, so I'm just going to say the always-reliable phrase: whatever.