kk650 said:

Cheers for the prompt replies! I once again agree with you two that in the second screencap R2D2 looks more 'natural' to me so that's the one to go with.

One last question. Taking into account the fleshtones of luke and uncle owen, getting the colour of C3P0 and R2D2 right and everything else, which of these two screencaps do you prefer, the first or the second?

The fleshtones look really off to me in both shots, and looking on the scopes they are well off the skintone line.

It can be useful to isolate the faces from the scene to look for colour-cast.

It looks too greenish-yellow to me.

Quick quiz for everyone out there, which of the two screenshots is the image above from?

This is Luke on Tatooine with the skintone right on the line on the scopes.

But of course one can make the faces pinkish or greenish or bright blue, it is upto the colourist what direction they want to go in with any given scene.

So, in the end, just do the grade that you like the best, if you ask 20 people for opinion on colour, you will get 20 different answers.