TheBoost said:
Many atheists would disagree strongly with this:
Nothing in an atheistic cosmology ultimately matters in the end.
You said that I was pigeonholing atheists and telling them what it was they believed in; giving my own opinion on atheistic cosmology doesn't mean that I think atheists share that opinion.
TheBoost said:
as well as any religion that doesn't believe in an afterlife.
Of course they would.
Perhaps I should have made it clear that I'm aware that not all religions believe in the existence of an afterlife, that the existence of a god/higher power doesn't necessarily mean that life has any meaning, and found a way to incorporate it all into my central argument.