OBI-WAN37 said:

(I'm not misspelling any words).

Hey, his argument may be awful, but at least he didn't misspell anything.

OBI-WAN37 said:

And the climatic duel on mustafar!

Well, anyone could spell climactic as climatic--heck, maybe he was referring to the warm climate in which the duel took place, right? Of course, he missed capitalizing several words (such as proper names and the beginnings of sentences within quotes), improperly formed a sentence out of a dependent clause (see the second quote), and created lengthy sentences filled with commas where we should have periods and new sentences. Too bad there are other spots where he should have put commas but neglected to do so. His grammar is poor, his syntax improper (such as incorrect subject-verb agreement), and his supporting evidence incorrect. For instance, no real volcanoes were filmed for Episode III. I see no need to even address the actual substance of the argument for two reasons: 1) unless he can present it more effectively, it is not really worth debating; 2) everyone else who reads this thread will tear his argument to shreds anyway.

And there could be a third reason: because it's Sam.

(Actually, I don't know for sure that's true--I think I've turned into a modern-day McCarthy, suspecting everyone of subversive Sam-unist activities. Please don't ban me for my juvenile speculation.)