I loved Lincoln but some of his modern stuff is hit or miss.

Crystal Skull is an aberration really though and its not as bad as i thought back in 2008. Its still the worst of the 4 films.

Can Kathy be forgiven for KOTCS yeah i think so as long as Star Wars VII at least hits its mark. Makes tons of money but a critical failure like episodes I and II i cannot see happening. Nor can i see total box office bomb like john carter or lone ranger. The critics can get it wrong they mostly loved Indiana Jones IV and Star Wars episode III. So if episode VII is even in the level of quality of those it will do well.