Wow, within 16 hours or posting last I got this many responses! Well, unfortunately there is repeated Jimbo rudeness. Jimbo it certainly is out of line to ask about how she is in bed. she is very beautiful and I am lucky to have her, thanks for all the positive comments from other posters. I thought this would be an interesting thread not only because it is indeed the love of my life that is interested in Star Wars and thinking about it on a philosophical level, but also that she is new to it and what is old and "original" to her is not gospel and is not necessarily better, simply because it was original. So I was curious to see what she thought was better when comparing the two. Like I said she puts the OT in the same order we all do 1. TESB 2.ANH 3. ROTJ She likes the MF edits over the I & II lucas put out. She disliked most of the changes lucas made, except cosmetic ones. She liked when I explained the deleted scenes with Luke and Biggs. Again, the most interesting and one of the most controversial changes she liked (but disliked pretty much all others) was the Hayden Ghost. I like the original again, because I've seen them 100 times and changing them seems like herecy. What was cool about her statements was she was thinking about it, grasping the concepts and into it. Again, she says the Obi-Wan explains that "when that happened your father, the jedi...died" He does not disappear, as she says, when he dies like the other Jedi Qui-gon, Obi-wan, and yoda. Luke has to burn his body on the funeral pyre for him to appear with Yoda and Obi-wan. These were all her statements without me prodding or leading her any way. I just thought...damn, I got to give her SOME credit on this one. I still like the old way, but its not as bad now. Mostly the changes I hate is the cartoony stuff...like the Jedi rocks scene and the Jabba scene in ANH and the Greedo scene of course is retarded (all of which she agreed) and thats why I dislike so much of the PT b/c there is so many of those scenes...episode I is like the jedi rocks Music video expanded to 2 hours of VH1's behind the Music with Jar-Jar as the lead singer. Irritating. So glad to see all the posts to this thread. And yeah I love my girl. We get married in March!