ray_afraid said:

Total BS. If Ady had said from the get-go that he planned to do many of the things Ronster has now proposed, most of you would call the decisions "brilliant".

Agreed. Nobody called it nitpicking when Ady made the dead stormtrooper's head fall faster in the opening battle sequence of ANH:R. Just because Ronster focuses more on audio than video does not mean he shouldn't share the discrepancies he finds. As with anything else on this forum, they are suggestions that Ady can choose to make, totally ignore, or provide justification as to why he will be leaving things as they are (all of which we have seen him do given the myriad of ideas that are voiced). Everyone here is a huge fan of this film. Since ESB:R (and other projects) aim to correct the inconsistencies, I'm all for people approaching this with a "no stone left unturned" attitude.