2. No darkened sky
3. Again, no
4. Im ok with these Dewbacks
5. Im ok with this shot of the Sandcrawler
6. No touched up Landspeeder
7. No new Obi-Wan hut shot
8. No Landspeeder touchups
9. No enhanced Mos Eisley shot
10. No digital speeder
11. No new Mos Eisley
12. No barking Dewback
13. Bring back the wolfman
14. No new Dewbacks
15. Han shoots first!!!
16. No digital droid
17. No digital air traffic
18. Remove the Jabba scene - DEFINITELY REMOVE, COMPLETELY
19. I dont mind this shot of the Falcon, I think its neat
20. No arching Falcon
21. I dont mind the explosions, but if it came to a vote, id vote KEEP THE OLD ONES.
22. I think this isnt very important, I like the TIE
23. No
24. No, a hallway's a hallway
25. No, maintain the old creature, and old colors
26. Leave the old
27. Keep this bit, it was in the OTR
28. NO, KEEP THE OLD ONES (except see below)
29. I dont mind this so much, when the shot is looking down the lightsaber it looks real weird, so the change is ok.
30. No
31. I dont mind this one
32. No
33. No
34. No
35. Yes, but only in its entirety - I agree
36. No
37. No
38. original - second this, KEEP ORIGINAL
39. No
40. I like the real people better
41. Obviously we need the OTR scene here, no "force ripples effecting the crystals in his lightsaber, etc" (thanks to the asshat starwars.com fanboys for that one (see the thread for laughs)
42. I dont think this is a very big deal, the only problem is you have to change the clock too for the Yavin approach - since we cant do that, I say leave the old and keep it consistent.
Thanks to Darth Justin for something I can copy/paste without pics, that was a big post anyways. Hal this is a great idea, I hope we really get a quality version out of this. Im awaiting the ESB changes.
ONE NOTE - we might want to stipulate that we have the old discussion between Tarkin and Leia, since the DVD versions have a weird audio level drop off, problem. Aside from that, this looks like a great list.