Tack said:
Have at it! Likes, dislikes, favourites, least-favourites! All is welcome!
For the record (all IMO):
Best Overall: Scrooge (1951)
Best for sheer accuracy: A Christmas Carol (1972, Animated)
Worst : Christmas Carol: The Movie (2001, Animated)
Agree on 1951 being the best. It has been the only performance where the actor seemed to really inhabit the character and make the transformation believable.