darklordoftech said:
DuracellEnergizer said:
darklordoftech said:
DuracellEnergizer said:
darklordoftech said:SilverWook said:
The crux of the argument is this: Does the Empire fall in a day after ROTJ, or does it take some time? The Special Edition would have you believe in instant collapse. The original version mostly leaves it up to the mind of the viewer.
There's several sources from 1983 that suggest that the intent was always instant collapse. Making of ROTJ is full of references to the Empire dying with Palpatine and the ROTJ novelization ends with the words, "The Empire is dead."
Only what shows up on screen matters. Authorial intent, supplimentary material, and various behind-the-scenes comments don't matter.
Tell Thrawn that.
Placing the Thrawn Trilogy in my own personal canon =/= the Thrawn Trilogy's validity outside of my own personal canon.
Nice strawman argument, though.
You're the one using the strawman argument. You have repeatedly insisted that the Thrawn trilogy is absolutely canon and flamed anybody who doesn't acknowledge it.
Wow, are you blind, for two main reasons:
1. I've never insisted that anything -- be it the Thrawn Trilogy, other EU works, or Shabby Blue's porn -- is "absolutely canon".
2. I flamed you (not everyone, just you) for saying the entire EU (of which the Thrawn Trilogy is only a part) was worse than the PT and providing few-to-no good reasons for why it was so, not because you didn't accept it or parts of it as canon. I don't give a shit about what others consider canon.