logo Sign In

Post #672098

Author
SpilkaBilka
Parent topic
ROTJ is the best Star Wars film... discuss!
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/672098/action/topic#672098
Date created
18-Nov-2013, 8:49 AM

I hated T3 at first, but after a few viewings it's gotten a little better.  There are a couple good parts mixed in with the bad (great ending), so I agree with the overall "meh."  T2 is my favorite.

I only bring up T3, because to me, it's basically a spoof of T2.  And to a much lesser degree, that's how I view Last Crusade: as practically a spoof of Raiders.  Sure, Raiders had humor, but Crusade just had WAY too much.  The tone was off- it just doesn't appeal to me because it isn't as gritty.

It is a good movie in its own right, but IMO it doesn't even come close to Raiders.

Raiders - 10 (yep, a perfect movie IMO)

Doom - 4.5? (though I must say it is the greatest horror movie for 12 year olds ever made)

Crusade - 6.5